When S/He Leaves You for Not Wanting Kids: Jerk! (or Justified?)

No WayMy not wanting to have children contributed to the end of my first two marriages.

I was young for the first marriage, and I didn’t really know until after Bill (not his real name) and I were about a year into being married that I didn’t want kids. He, on the other hand, wanted 1. A House 2. A Nice Car 3. A Family. So, that was that. (It didn’t help our relationship that “soul mate/partner/wife” wasn’t an item on that list, but was lumped in with “family.” I knew even at 19/20 years old that if I ever did for whatever reason decide to have kids, I wanted to be a partner first and a mother second–appreciated for more than the fact that I was “the mother of his children.”)

The second time I got married, I knew I didn’t want kids, but Ted (not his real name) didn’t believe I knew it. When I finally got him to accept that I’d been telling the truth the whole time and not playing the coy “No, I don’t wants kids” (“Of course I do! Tee hee!”) game – you know, that one – that was pretty much the end of us (we’d been on our way to ending, anyway, but the No Child in My Womb initiative clinched it).

I used to be pretty resentful of the fact that whether or not I’d have children helped along their decision to let the relationship die. If they loved me, wouldn’t they want to be with me no matter what? How could they love some unborn, imaginary child more than an actual person? How could they take their chances with some other woman they might not love the same way they love me just because she’d be willing to get pregnant?

“They must not really love me,” I thought, and, “Someone who would leave me over the mere idea of a child doesn’t deserve me, anyway.”

As I discuss in No Children, No Guilt, this was pretty flawed – hypocritical, even – thinking.

After all, I was willing to let the relationship die because they wanted children. I wasn’t willing to consider changing the life I envisioned to make them stay. I didn’t love them enough to do something I didn’t want to do.

Even now, married to a man I can’t imagine ever being without, if he suddenly told me he wanted children, we would probably end up getting divorced.

Just as my exes weren’t willing to stay with me without children, I wasn’t, and am not, willing to have children to stay with a man.

As I wrote in No Children, No Guilt (and I think I can get away with not using quotation marks if I’m quoting myself), what I understand now, and what my need to feel done wrong and wounded had me refusing to understand then, is that someone’s desire to have a baby is just as strong as someone’s desire not to. If something extraordinary isn’t keeping two people together, it’s no easier for a person who wants children to stay child-free with someone than it is for someone who has never wanted children to imagine having one they don’t want — even if what’s between the two is something close to real love.

To have children or not is a lifestyle choice, and if two people have opposing, but equally strong, feelings about that choice, it’s not a comment on the love or lack thereof if someone leaves, but a pursuit of what each person wants/needs in his or her life. If those needs aren’t compatible, the relationship won’t work (unless someone makes a change and does it without being resentful).

So, like, cut the guys (or gals) who ditch you for kids some slack. You’re not so different from them.

~ ~ ~

What Every Woman Wishes Modern Men Knew About Women

“A weird combo of really funny and really insightful.”


5 thoughts on “When S/He Leaves You for Not Wanting Kids: Jerk! (or Justified?)

  1. I think if the woman does not want children in a marriage she should not have children. Childcare still falls much harder on the woman than the man. I am amazed what men can still get away with in terms of childcare.

    In my marriage I was a fencesitter and my husband was the definitive no and told me before the marriage that he was not going change. I perhaps did under estimate that he was a firm NO.

    However, I thought I would only want a child(not children) if there was 50/50 parenting with the husband. 95 percent of the time the childcare falls on the owman.

  2. Emily

    Generally I don’t blame either party (childfree or wanting-children) if there’s a change of heart or lack of previous communication. But if someone just decides to disregard what the other person is saying (e.g. Ted) then they’re at fault for a lot. I’m not saying the entire divorce/breakup should be blamed on that person, there’s always enough blame to spread around. But assuming “I want X” really means “I don’t want X” is the kind of game playing I really can’t stand, particularly in a relationship.

  3. Most people date incorrectly. They get the physical match down easily enough, but ignore the morals/values/ethics match up completely. Most also ignore everything their date says to them. I read somewhere that women don’t listen to anything men say in the first few dates, and that’s a huge mistake. (In my experience, it goes both ways. Men are just as guilty.) Everything you should know about a person, they’ll tell you in those few inital dates. Like, does s/he want kids? Is s/he open to kids and family, or not? Is s/he dead set against this or that? What we should be doing is a mental checklist. If there aren’t enough matches down your morals, values and ethics colums with your date mate, move along. Don’t – nay, STOP – wasting each other’s time. They will understand and appreciate your decision when you tell them you two aren’t a good match and why. No one can argue with that. Being in love is over-rated. Staying is love is vastly under-rated. Staying in love is hard enough, but when you decide to hitch your wagon to someone who is so different from you, wants opposite things in life…? Why do that to yourself? I never get what people do that to themselves. It’s baffling to me. The couple in any relationship (married or not), is the primary entity. Without a solid foundation and companionship between the couple, adding kids to the mix will only ensure distasterous results sooner rather than later. Just ask Katy Perry and Russell Brand. I believe their marriage crumbled under the weight of opposing priorities in life and lack of compatibility overall. Remember, kids: it’s just as easy to fall in love with a garbage man as it is a prince. And 9x out of 10, the garbage man will be a better partner for you than the prince even if the lifestyle is fabulous and glamourous.

  4. Nast

    I don’t want kids. Knowing that, why in the hell would I seriously commit(marriage, common law) with someone who does? I don’t get people


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s